Andi Mack Wiki
Andi Mack Wiki

I may not be able to un-sing what I sang. But I can re-sing it.

Jonah to Andi

Hole in the Wall is the fourth episode in Season 3 of Andi Mack and the forty-first overall. It first aired on November 2, 2018 to 0.67 million viewers.[1]



Andi is embarrassed when Jonah performs a song about her; Bowie decides to renovate Bex and Andi’s apartment to make it big enough for their whole family to live in; Buffy conducts her first girls’ basketball team tryouts.[2]

Full Plot

With Bex and Bowie's wedding coming up, the new family will need a bigger place to stay after they're married. Bowie and Bex break the news to Andi about getting a bigger place. Instead of being excited, Andi is upset that her parents made the decision to move without consulting her. She loves the apartment and she doesn't want to move at all. To Andi's surprise, Bowie goes to the apartment next door and knocks a hole in the wall, announcing that they just bought the adjacent apartment to merge it with the current one. Andi is glad they don't have to move after all.

At school, Buffy is finally holding tryouts for the new girls basketball team she's starting. TJ and Cyrus come along to give her the emotional support she needs. Despite them expecting her to be nervous, Buffy is confident and not nervous at all. She walks into the room and finds a group of girls waiting for her. She gives them instructions on how to play and blows the whistle to get them started. Unfortunately, it turns out that they're all terrible at basketball. She asks them to take a break. She tells Cyrus and TJ that she is worried if the team is so bad, they are never going to be able to find anyone willing to coach them. She says they're terrible but TJ reminds her that she has to be patient with everyone and not to turn into the kind of captain he was.

At round two of the tryouts, no one shows up, making Buffy really worried. She has no option but to stick with those who tried out in the first round, despite how terrible they were. She realizes that she could boost their team spirit if she made them look like a team. At that point, she reminds TJ that he still owes her a favor for being mean to her. She asks TJ to help get a team uniform for the girls. TJ comes through and Buffy hands over the uniform to the girls team. The girls team loves their new uniform. So, they keep walking around in it in groups.

At Red Rooster Records, Andi and Jonah Beck are having fun taking pictures together as friends. Andi brings up how proud she is for their invention of the "no-breakup breakup." They both love that they're having so much fun together as friends without all the complications of relationships. Afterwards, Bowie tells Jonah that he has an open mic night but he doesn't have anyone who signed up to perform. So, he asks Jonah to perform but Jonah complains that he doesn't have any other song besides the one he wrote for Andi.[3] Bowie insists and Jonah promises to come up with something.

During the open-mic night, Jonah goes to the stage. Andi, Buffy and Cyrus are in the audience to cheer him on. Jonah starts singing. It turns out to be a song about the night he said goodbye to Andi before leaving for the frisbee camp.[4] In the song, he says that he walked her to the door to say goodbye and she cried. The song makes it sound as if Andi was so devastated about the break up. Everyone in the audience starts looking at Andi, concerned if she's okay. But Andi makes it clear that she is fine. After the song, Andi complains that that's not how it went down.

The next day, Andi confronts Jonah about the song. Jonah apologizes and says that he can't un-sing it. But maybe he can re-sing it. So, during lunch, he takes on his guitar and starts performing the song to the students. Except this time, it's a different version in which he admits that he's the one who cried. After the song, Andi and Jonah make up and resume hanging out together as friends. They declare themselves the best exes ever.

Andi says that she and Jonah can handle anything that comes their way, no matter what buttons are pushed. Even if it's the biggest button of all - dating other people. At that point, Jonah gets a weird look on his face and then leaves abruptly.


Main Cast

Peyton Elizabeth Lee as Andi Mack
Joshua Rush as Cyrus Goodman
Sofia Wylie as Buffy Driscoll
Asher Angel as Jonah Beck
Trent Garrett as Bowie Quinn
Lilan Bowden as Bex Mack
Lauren Tom as Celia Mack (credit only)

Recurring Cast

Luke Mullen as TJ Kippen


Andi Mack Logo.jpeg
To view the Hole in the Wall gallery, click here.


  • This is the first appearance of TJ in Season 3.
  • This is the second time Jonah performs a song for Andi; the first was in Andi's Choice.
  • The scene where Andi and Jonah take photos of various album covers over their faces seems to reference this radio station scene from the 2012 movie Pitch Perfect.


Andi Mack Episodes
Season 1
13Outside the BoxShhh!Dancing in the DarkIt's Not About YouShe Said, She SaidDad InfluenceTerms of EmbarrassmentShe's Turning Into YouHome Away From HomeWere We Ever?Best Surprise Ever
Season 2
Hey, Who Wants Pizza?Chinese New YearFriends Like TheseMamaThe SnorpionI Wanna Hold Your WristbandHead Over HeelsThere's a Mack in the ShackYou're the One That I WantA Good Hair DayMiniature GulfWe Were NeverCyrus' Bash-Mitzvah!Better to Have Wuvved and WostPerfect Day 2.0Truth or TruthA Walker to RememberCrime Scene: AndiShack!Andi's ChoiceFor the Last TimeBuffy in a BottleKeep a Lid on ItBought, Lost or StolenWe're on Cloud TenThe Cake That Takes the Cake
Season 3
The Boys are BackHowling at the Moon FestivalIt's a DilemmaHole in the WallThat Syncing FeelingCookie MonsterThe New GirlsI Got Your NumberSecret SocietyThe QuacksOne in a MinyanThe Ex FactorMount Rushmore or LessHammer TimeUnloading ZoneOne Girl's TrashArts and InhumanitiesSomething to Talk A-BootA Moving DayWe Were Here