Jonah. Walker. Two guys.
At Red Rooster Records, Bowie asks Jonah about his audition with Sid and Jonah reveals that he never made it because something else came up. Jonah had panicked after seeing a painting by Andi and Walker at the art gallery on his way. Jonah tells Bowie that he thinks Andi doesn't like him anymore. So, Bowie advises him to do a big gesture for Andi by writing her a song and performing it on stage. At first, Jonah is not comfortable with the plan but Bowie gives him courage and helps him write the song.
Andi is at The Spoon waiting for Buffy and Cyrus when she gets a call from Walker. He wants to hangout with her but Andi says that she is spending time with Buffy and Cyrus because Buffy is about to leave. Buffy brings a bag with all the items that Andi and Cyrus have left at her house over the years. While The Good Hair Crew is going through the items, Walker arrives and tells them that he wanted to meet Buffy before she leaves town. He asks to make a painting of Andi, Buffy and Cyrus together. After Walker is gone, Buffy and Cyrus ask Andi about her relationship with him. They are surprised that Andi now has two guys who like her. They tell her that she has to make a choice between Jonah and Walker. While they're still at The Spoon, Jonah comes over and hands them invitations to his performance.
Before the performance on stage, Jonah is a little scared of the crowd but Bowie helps him by revealing that he used to look at Bex to gain confidence when performing. Jonah begins playing his song Being Around You. He starts out shy but uses Bowie's advice and looks at Andi. This boosts his confidence so much that he performs the song perfectly and wows the crowd. Buffy and Cyrus notice that the song is about Andi. After Jonah's performance, Andi walks towards Jonah. Buffy and Cyrus stay behind to watch.
Andi gets close to Jonah and holds his hand. She then leans close and gives him a kiss on the lips. Andi and Jonah share their first kiss.
Meanwhile, Bex is shocked when her boss Brittany accuses her of writing fake positive online reviews for herself. Bex denies writing them. She looks at the reviews and figures out that it must be CeCe who has been writing them. A few moments later, a woman, Zoe, who runs a rival business, comes to The Fringe and accuses Bex of writing a fake negative review. Bex denies it but the name of the fake reviewer matches one of Bex's positive reviewers. So, Bex goes to Celia's house to confront her about it. CeCe admits that she wrote the fake reviews to help promote Bex. She insists that Bex deserves better, especially since she completed her cosmetology school. Bex agrees but asks CeCe to stay out of it and help her figure out things on her own.
The next day at The Fringe, Bex is shocked when CeCe comes over and reveals that she has bought The Fringe for Bex. This makes Bex the new owner of The Fringe.
- Peyton Elizabeth Lee as Andi Mack
- Joshua Rush as Cyrus Goodman
- Sofia Wylie as Buffy Driscoll
- Asher Angel as Jonah Beck
- Lilan Bowden as Bex Mack
- Lauren Tom as Celia Mack
- KayCee Stroh as Zoe
| To view the Andi's Choice gallery, click here.
- Andi kissed Jonah for the first time.
- The "Welp" titled app is a play on the "Yelp" app.
- Kaycee Stroh from the High School Musical franchise makes an appearance in this episode (Kenny Ortega directs the High School Musical movies and he was going to direct this episode but unfortunately he does not).
- Bowie helps Jonah write a song to perform at the open mic called “Being Around You” to attempt to be with Andi.